← Argue and win

Be more persuasive: three chairs

Some people win you over with facts, others with a story, others because you trust them. Here you argue one topic each way in turn, then mix all three into one talk.

1Debate

Should you forgive people who never apologize?

1 / 100
1/500:30

A topic appears on the screen.

Why it works

Most of us persuade in one way only. Analytical people stack facts and lose the room; warm people tell stories and have nothing to say to “where's the proof?” The listener needs all three: a reason to agree, a feeling that it matters and a sense that you're worth listening to. This is the old split into logos, pathos and ethos, and it still holds.

Splitting them up shows which one you lean on and which one you skip. Pure logic with no emotion is hard, and that's the point: you find out how much each one carries on its own. When you mix them at the end, you choose each piece on purpose instead of by habit.

Common mistakes

  • Letting the chairs blur. A story slips into the logic round, a number into the emotion round. Keep each version pure, or you lose the contrast.
  • Mistaking trust for bragging. The trust chair isn't “I'm an expert, believe me”. It's experience, shared values and showing that you understand the other side.
  • Making up numbers in the logic round. If you don't know the figure, use cause and effect: “if this happens, then that follows”.
  • Gluing three speeches together in the final round. A good mix is one argument with a fact, an image and a personal note woven in.

Questions

What are the three ways to persuade someone?
Logic (reasons, facts, cause and effect), emotion (stories, images, what the listener feels) and trust (who you are and why your view deserves weight). Classical rhetoric calls them logos, pathos and ethos.
Which one is the most persuasive?
It depends on the listener. A finance team needs numbers first; a tired friend needs to feel heard. That's why you train all three: to pick the one that fits, not the one you're used to.
How do I practice persuasion on my own?
Out loud, with a timer, on topics you didn't choose. Record the final mixed round on your phone and listen back: does it sound like one argument or like three speeches stuck together?
Does this help at work or in sales?
The topics are general, but the skill carries over: a pitch to your manager or a client uses the same three levers. Before a real conversation, run your own topic through the three chairs.

More exercises